Could Steve Levitt get into a top economics Ph.D. program today?

That’s a good question, given how competitive it seems to have gotten and how little math preparation I had. Just this year we saw a 20% increase in applications to the U of C program (my colleagues blamed me for all the extra work that made, saying it was a Freakonomics effect).

The question of whether I could get into grad school today is being debated in the following thread.

I think the answer is that MIT and/or Harvard might still take a chance on me today, but not the other top places including the University of Chicago. At U of C, my application would be thrown out before ever getting to a faculty member, just as would have been the case 15 years ago.

I am lucky that MIT was willing to roll the dice.

TAGS:

Leave A Comment

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

 

COMMENTS: 48

  1. Antichron says:

    Well, to support your colleagues’ claim, Freakonomics was the primary reason I applied to Chicago. (Though the writing sample almost scared me away!)

    Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  2. Antichron says:

    Well, to support your colleagues’ claim, Freakonomics was the primary reason I applied to Chicago. (Though the writing sample almost scared me away!)

    Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  3. chicago_chris says:

    Isn’t uchicago asking quite a lot to expect both strong math preparation and a twenty-page writing sample?

    I think most of its own econ undergrads would have trouble meeting that requirement. I graduated from the uchicago math/econ program and don’t recall writing anything longer than ten pages.

    Is the faculty also upset about the Friedman and Becker effects?

    Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  4. chicago_chris says:

    Isn’t uchicago asking quite a lot to expect both strong math preparation and a twenty-page writing sample?

    I think most of its own econ undergrads would have trouble meeting that requirement. I graduated from the uchicago math/econ program and don’t recall writing anything longer than ten pages.

    Is the faculty also upset about the Friedman and Becker effects?

    Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  5. Robert Schwartz says:

    Could you enlighten us outsiders on what it takes to get into grad school in econ? Grades, test scores, majors?

    Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  6. Robert Schwartz says:

    Could you enlighten us outsiders on what it takes to get into grad school in econ? Grades, test scores, majors?

    Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  7. chicago_chris says:

    To be a shoe-in at a top school, you’ll probably need a high GPA (> 3.7), high GRE (800Q or maybe slightly less), good math prep (coursework in real analysis a must, functional analysis or metric spaces even better), three good letters of recommendation from economists, and proven research experience.

    I’d say it’s pretty competitive. I had the GPA, GRE, and math prep, plus unrelated (math) research experience and just two letters of recommendation from economists, and I went 1 for 10.

    I think that’s maybe a little too competitive.

    Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  8. chicago_chris says:

    To be a shoe-in at a top school, you’ll probably need a high GPA (> 3.7), high GRE (800Q or maybe slightly less), good math prep (coursework in real analysis a must, functional analysis or metric spaces even better), three good letters of recommendation from economists, and proven research experience.

    I’d say it’s pretty competitive. I had the GPA, GRE, and math prep, plus unrelated (math) research experience and just two letters of recommendation from economists, and I went 1 for 10.

    I think that’s maybe a little too competitive.

    Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0